Skip to main content
Social Media Management

Should You Hire a Social Media Manager for Your Small Business?

By Mikenzie Rae Melendez
Small business owner checking a smartphone with a coffee at a cafe table beside a laptop, with the title Hire a Social Media Manager for a Small Business

Short answer: Hire a social media manager for your small business when posting has become inconsistent, you are losing hours a week to it, or messages and comments sit unanswered. For most small businesses an agency or experienced freelancer costs less than a new employee. Start with clear goals, access and an approval process, then judge results after 90 days.

Most owners do not wake up wanting a social media manager. They wake up to a Facebook page that has not posted since spring, a few unanswered messages and the feeling that a competitor down the road looks busier online. This guide walks through the decision: whether you are ready, which kind of help fits, and how to set the first month up so the hire actually works.

How do I know my small business is ready to hire a social media manager?

You are ready when social media matters to how customers find or judge you and it is not getting done well. A few signs we see over and over:

  • Posting comes in bursts. Three posts in a week, then nothing for two months. Customers who check your page see a business that looks closed.
  • Messages and comments wait days. A question in your inbox is often a buyer. A slow reply sends them to the next search result.
  • You are spending your best hours on it. If an owner who bills or sells for a living spends five hours a week making posts, the time has a real price.
  • Nothing connects to your website. Posts go out, but nobody is pointing people to the pages and offers that bring in leads.

You may not be ready if you have not decided who your customer is or what you want them to do. A manager can carry out a plan, but the offer, prices and service area still have to come from you.

Should I hire an in-house social media manager, a freelancer or an agency?

All three can work. The right one depends on how much content you need, how much you can spend and how much managing you want to do yourself.

In-house employee

An employee knows your business best and is in the building when something worth posting happens. The trade-off is cost and coverage. A salary is only part of what an employee costs. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that in June 2026, wages and salaries made up 70.0 percent of private industry employer compensation costs and benefits made up the other 30.0 percent (BLS Employer Costs for Employee Compensation). You also take on hiring, training, software and covering vacations. For a small business that needs a few posts a week, that is often more than the job requires.

Freelancer

A good freelancer can be flexible and affordable. The risks are capacity and continuity: one person, one set of skills, and nobody covering when they are sick or booked up. Freelancers also tend to focus on posting alone, so your social can drift away from your website, Google Business Profile and search work.

Agency

An agency gives you a team, a process and backup, usually at a set monthly price. The trade-off is that you need to stay involved enough to keep the content sounding like you. The best fit is an agency that ties social media to the rest of your online presence instead of treating it as a separate feed.

What does a social media manager actually do each week?

The title covers more than posting. A useful manager handles a repeatable cycle:

  1. Plan. A calendar built around your services, seasons and offers, so posts have a reason to exist.
  2. Create and schedule. Writing captions, choosing or producing images and video, and scheduling posts on the platforms that fit your customers.
  3. Engage. Replying to comments, flagging messages that are really sales inquiries, and keeping the conversation going.
  4. Report. Showing what was posted and what happened, in plain language you can act on.

If you want to compare how a scope reads in practice, our Social Media Management page lists exactly what ours includes.

What should I hand over before a social media manager starts?

The first 30 days decide whether the relationship works. Most stalled starts come from missing access or unclear approvals, not bad content. Have these ready:

  • Access. Add the manager as a partner or admin through each platform's business tools, such as Meta Business Suite for Facebook and Instagram, instead of sharing your personal password.
  • Brand basics. Your logo files, colors, any photos you own and a few posts you have liked from other businesses.
  • Business facts. Services, service area, hours, prices you are comfortable posting and anything you never want said publicly.
  • An approval rule. Decide what needs your sign-off first and what can go out on its own. A weekly batch approval keeps things moving.
  • A photo habit. Real photos of your team, jobs and customers outperform stock images. A shared folder you drop phone photos into helps a lot.

How do I measure whether hiring a social media manager is working?

Pick a few numbers before you start, and give it about 90 days before you judge. Social builds over time, and the first month is mostly setup.

  • Consistency. Did posts go out on the agreed schedule every week?
  • Response time. Are comments and messages answered quickly?
  • Actions, not just likes. Website clicks, calls, direction requests and messages that turn into quotes or bookings.
  • Where leads say they found you. Ask every new customer. It is free and it is the most honest data you will get.

Social media also feeds the places AI assistants and Google read about your business. A steady, accurate presence supports the work we describe in how to show up in AI search results.

How much does it cost to hire a social media manager through Mikenzie Rae Media?

Every price is on our pricing page. On the a la carte list, Social Media Management is $400 per month for 2 to 3 posts per week, including content posting, audience engagement and brand growth. It is also included in our packages: Presence ($499 per month) includes social media management at 1 to 2 posts per week, Growth ($999 per month) includes 3 to 4 posts per week, and Total Domination ($4,999 per month) includes full social media management across every platform. Every package includes a website built by us, with a $2,000 one time website build fee.

If you want to compare what other providers charge and what drives the price, see how much social media management costs per month. If you are in Southern Maine and want questions to ask any provider before signing, read our guide to social media management in Saco, Biddeford and Portland. You can also buy services a la carte instead of a package.

Talk to Mikenzie

Not sure whether you need a social media manager yet? Contact Mikenzie at (207) 222-7098 or mikenzie@mikenzieraemedia.com and tell us what you are trying to grow. Mikenzie Rae Media LLC is at 230 Main Street, Suite 102, Saco, ME 04072.

Header photo: Woman sitting in cafe using smartphone by Shixart1985, CC BY 2.0.

FAQ

When should a small business hire a social media manager?
When social media matters to how customers find or judge you and it is not getting done well: posting is inconsistent, messages wait days, or the owner is spending several hours a week on it.
Is it cheaper to hire a social media agency or an employee?
For most small businesses that need a few posts a week, an agency or experienced freelancer costs less than an employee. BLS data show benefits are about 30 percent of private industry employer compensation costs, on top of hiring and training.
What should I give a new social media manager?
Partner or admin access through each platform's business tools, your logo and brand colors, real photos, your services and service area, and a clear rule for what needs your approval before it posts.
How long before social media management shows results?
Give it about 90 days. The first month is mostly setup and planning. Judge consistency, response time and real actions such as calls, clicks and messages, not likes alone.
How much is social media management at Mikenzie Rae Media?
Social Media Management is $400 per month on the a la carte list for 2 to 3 posts per week. Presence ($499), Growth ($999) and Total Domination ($4,999) per month include it at different levels.

Want this working for your business?

Talk to Mikenzie, or start with a free scan.

Call (207) 222-7098Send a noteSee PricingGet your free RAEDAR Score

Related service: Social Media Marketing